130th Constitution Amendment Bill: Concerns over politicization of arrest power for Ministers
The 130th Constitution (Amendment) Bill, referred to a Joint Parliamentary Committee, is presented as the Union government's solution to political corruption, aiming to prevent Ministers, including PMs and CMs, from governing from jail. The Bill proposes that Ministers arrested for serious offenses (punishable by five years or more imprisonment) and incarcerated as undertrials for 30 days would lose office automatically on the 31st day or by presidential/gubernatorial order. The Opposition deems it unconstitutional, fearing it could destabilize elected governments and politicize the power of arrest. Supreme Court judgments have cautioned against using arrest as harassment, emphasizing that the power to arrest does not always necessitate its exercise, and that deprivation of liberty, even for a single day, is a serious matter.
Key Points
- The 130th Constitution (Amendment) Bill seeks to remove Ministers, PMs, and CMs from office if arrested and detained for 30 days for serious offenses.
- The Bill is intended to combat political corruption but is criticized by the Opposition as unconstitutional and a tool for destabilizing elected governments.
- Concerns are raised that the Bill politicizes the power of arrest, allowing for potential misuse against ministers in opposition-ruled states.
- Supreme Court rulings have consistently warned against incentivizing arrest and using it as a tool for harassment or punishment.
- The Bill's timing coincides with Supreme Court's criticism of low conviction rates in cases under anti-money laundering laws, highlighting issues with arrest powers.
Exam Facts
- The Bill is the Constitution (One Hundred and Thirtieth Amendment) Bill.
- It proposes removal of ministers if incarcerated as undertrials for 30 days for offenses punishable by five years or more.
- Supreme Court cases cited: Arnesh Kumar versus State of Bihar, Joginder Kumar Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, Arnab Ranjan Goswami versus Union of India.
- The Bill has been referred to a Joint Parliamentary Committee.
Read it. Retain it. Recall it.
Get spaced-repetition flashcards, daily quizzes and offline access — free on Android.